Press "Enter" to skip to content
M. Gessen, 2024. Photo by Damon Winter/The New York Times.

Collective Ethics in an Autocratic Climate: M. Gessen Discusses the “Politics of the Past and Politics of the Future” 

What are our ethical obligations as students living, learning, and creating a politics of the future at Haverford College? We must establish a clear set of ethical principles that we are unwilling to compromise in the face of autocracy and fascism.

On Thursday, September 17, 2026, M. Gessen, a Pulitzer Prize-winning opinion writer for The New York Times, spoke at an event titled “Politics of the Past and Politics of the Future.” They discussed autocracy within the context of the second Trump administration, the political climate post-9/11, the structural function of institutions, trans rights and people under attack, the Democratic Party’s current political and ethical role, the importance of local media in combating misinformation, as well as the creation of a future-oriented politics. 

The event was a joint presentation of The Michael B. Kim Institute for Ethical Inquiry and Leadership, the John B. Hurford ’60 Center for the Arts and Humanities, Haverford College Libraries, and the Center for Peace and Global Citizenship. Gessen has written 11 books, including the National Book Award-winning The Future Is History: How Totalitarianism Reclaimed Russia, Surviving Autocracy, and The Man Without a Face: The Unlikely Rise of Vladimir Putin. 

The discussion was moderated by Professor Zainab Saleh, associate professor of anthropology, Koshland Director of the Hurford Center for the Arts and Humanities, and author of Return to Ruin: Iraqi Narratives of Exile and Nostalgia and Political Undesirables: Citizenship, Denaturalization, and Reclamation in Iraq. 

M. Gessen began by emphasizing a turning point in recent U.S. history, namely 9/11. Gessen asserted that 9/11 marked the beginning of a “fortress under siege” mentality in the U.S. This mentality led to the creation of a surveillance state, including the Department of Homeland Security and the institutional structure that permits unmarked vehicles to arrest people on the streets today. Before 9/11, the U.S. “did not tell a story about being surrounded by enemies. It did not tell a story about being on the defensive. It did not tell a story of constant danger.” This narrative, invented 25 years ago, is what solidified the conditions for Trump to be able to talk about the “invasion” of immigrants today as if it were not so ludicrous. 

This invasion not only refers to immigrants, but other vulnerable minorities such as transgender individuals. Saleh asked Gessen why the vilification and dehumanization of trans people in Kansas should alarm us all, and how we should frame this systemic attack on trans people as a broader warning about the future of American democracy. Gessen indicated that the widespread concern for autocracy arose from individuals witnessing horrible acts of discrimination in other places and being fearful that those discriminatory practices could become relevant to their own lives. In their words: “That strikes me as a fundamentally immoral way of thinking about the world. We should not be concerned about Kansas because Kansas might happen in Pennsylvania. We should be concerned about Kansas because it is happening in Kansas.” Not only is the anti-trans legislation in Kansas overtly an attack on trans rights, but Gessen characterizes it as an “act of denationalization.” 

In February, trans people who had changed their gender marker on their identity documents found that their driver’s licenses had been revoked. Gessen remarked that it is simply inconvenient for the state to have the information on somebody’s documents be discordant with what they are looking at (ie., a transgender woman who was assigned male at birth will have an M marker on their driver’s license, disorienting the hypothetical officer who has pulled them over). The only rationale for the state of Kansas to enforce the change was to prioritize putting down the identification of a trans person as trans rather than as an individual. Gessen said this is reminiscent of a 1935 Nazi law which required all Jewish people to take on the middle name Sarah for women, and Israel for males to be identifiable as Jewish to the state. 

How can we collectively hold a firm stance against these grotesque and menacing acts of denationalization and targeted surveillance? 

Well, for one, in Surviving Autocracy, Gessen warns us not to trust that institutions can protect us from an autocratic takeover because our system is not designed to confront a leader like Trump. In a smaller, less formal session before the public event, Gessen emphasized that Trump is fundamentally hostile to knowledge, historical and scientific. His attacks on universities and the destruction of CDC data demonstrate this. They have emphasized in a Democracy Now! Interview titled “Imperialism and Totalitarianism Go Hand in Hand,” that Trump has been increasingly transformed by the power of surviving an assassination attempt and winning two elections during his second term. He weaponizes language by using words in a way that does not fit their proper meaning, by inverting them. His administration seeks to attack expressions of empathy, mutual interdependence, and mutual obligation within our institutions. He disregards presidential norms and codes of conduct that have historically been considered obligatory for presidents. His persistent attacks on knowledge, empathy, and language, paired with a crazed focus on power, are enough evidence to demonstrate that Trump is serious about destroying our cherished institutions. 

It is also valuable to pay close attention to Gessen’s critique of the Democratic Party to understand what kind of vision we have to construct in opposition to the autocratic one. Gessen stated that the Democrats do not challenge the status quo enough, including the disregard for trans rights and the normalization of ICE securitization. They argued that it is not enough for Democrats to define themselves in opposition to or ridicule autocrats, asserting simply that they are ‘not like Trump.’ Additionally, it is unacceptable to adopt an inactive strategy such as “playing dead” as a means of looking onward as the Republican Party folds in and destroys itself, as suggested by James Carville. As Gessen stated, “The only politics that works against autocrats is a politics of aspiration, a truly affirmative politics, a decisive politics, not a politics of criticizing the autocrats but a future oriented hopeful politics.”

While these criticisms were geared specifically towards the Democratic Party, the presence of a future-oriented, hopeful politics is relevant to our campus as well. 

During the informal conversation with students, students who had read excerpts of Surviving Autocracy asked how we might avoid trivializing Trump. It is safe to say that many of us on campus have likely found ourselves guilty of writing off the Trump administration as laughable. However, Gessen advises that we take Trump seriously because he has genuine imperialist and totalitarian aspirations, much like former autocrats. Perhaps rather than characterizing the MAGA movement as a demonstration of collective insanity, we instead might examine the roots of “Trumpism.” Trumpism refers to the centralization of power in the executive branch, the influence of wealth on politics, the degradation of political language, and the erosion of presidential decorum and obligations. 

There is a real rationale to the legitimation of autocratic rule. Gessen responded to a student’s query in the formal discussion regarding the connection between Erich Fromm’s work and the current political landscape. Fromm was a social psychologist who fled Nazi Germany and published a book called Escape from Freedom, which provided an explanation as to why people submit to autocratic rule. He noted that there are periods in history when people feel uncertain of their economic and social future, and they become uncomfortable with the freedom to invent themselves. They become so destabilized that they give their agency over to an autocrat. This phenomenon occurred in the 1930s in Germany, and is occurring again as economic anxieties are projected onto vulnerable minorities as a scapegoating mechanism. “What autocrats always promise and never deliver is stability.” How do we combat these insecurities? By painting a vision of the future that articulates the real possibility of coexistence and life in this country that does not necessitate an autocratic government. 

Another student illuminated a similar ethical inquiry to the one I posed at the beginning of this article. They asked, “What is the line between negotiating (with the Trump administration/Republican Party) and conceding our morality? How do we go about maintaining liberal morals and views but also still trying to get things done and keep going?” Gessen stated that what makes this line easier to discern is the establishment of a coherent body of ethics, of which the Democratic Party has none. As a Haverford community, it is imperative that we maintain a stable set of ethics in these troubling times. 

I see hope for our generation, especially among Haverford students. After all, we have one of the oldest and entirely student-run honor codes in the United States. We engage in democratic procedures such as Plenary and vote on representatives and council members. These Haverfordian traditions are of more significance than ever in an age where an autocratic party is in power. Our Center for Peace and Global Citizenship funds students each year to intern at NGOs on a local level, national level, and international level. This reflects a student and institutional commitment to engaging with human rights beyond our immediate community. As Gessen mentioned, “local media is the ultimate antidote against conspiracy thinking” because it gives us a shared sense of reality and grounds us in it. Bi-Co news outlets such as The Clerk and the Bi-Co News aim to preserve communal news in an age of widespread misinformation and political polarization. 

When a student in the informal session asked what we should do when people are so scared of autocratic regimes that they give in to their control, Gessen responded, “That’s a simple question; everyone can do something.” They added that if everyone did something a bit braver than what they thought they’d be capable of, such as protesting or speaking up, the possibility of political transformation would continue to exist. The combined simplicity and eloquence of this statement speaks volumes and should encourage students to reflect on what collective body of ethics and politics of vision they wish to see emulated in this country. 


Discover more from The Clerk

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *